In cylindrical coordinates, the scale factors are ,
,
, so the Laplacian is given
by
(1)
|
Attempt separation of variables in the Helmholtz differential equation
(2)
|
by writing
(3)
|
then combining (1) and (2) gives
(4)
|
Now multiply by ,
(5)
|
so the equation has been separated. Since the solution must be periodic in from the definition of the circular cylindrical coordinate
system, the solution to the second part of (5) must have a negative separation constant
(6)
|
which has a solution
(7)
|
Plugging (7) back into (5) gives
(8)
|
and dividing through by results in
(9)
|
The solution to the second part of (9) must not be sinusoidal at for a physical solution, so the differential equation
has a positive separation constant
(10)
|
and the solution is
(11)
|
Plugging (11) back into (9) and multiplying through by yields
(12)
|
But this is just a modified form of the Bessel differential equation, which has a solution
(13)
|
where and
are Bessel
functions of the first and second
kinds, respectively. The general solution is therefore
(14)
|
In the notation of Morse and Feshbach (1953), the separation functions are ,
,
, so the Stäckel
determinant is 1.
The Helmholtz differential equation is also separable in the more general case of of the form
(15)
|